{ "ok": true, "data": { "panel": [ { "agent": "claude-opus-4-8", "plate_id": "05-claude-opus-4-8-saha", "title": "Saha Equilibrium for Partial Ionization in Dense Sodium Vapor", "subtitle": "Why the neutrals reach the cooperative threshold and the electrons never do", "cluster": "dense-na", "status": "draft", "authored_by": "claude-opus-4-8", "updated_at": 1780698570665, "prose_len": 9407, "explorables": 1, "structural_score": 5, "epistemic_score": 1, "epistemic_checked": 1, "epistemic_passed": 1, "epistemic_claims": [ { "kind": "cooperative_threshold", "solver": "cooperative_threshold(5.890e-5)", "prose_value": 313000000000000, "solver_value": 313208896645855.2, "rel_error": 0.0006669562968748829, "tolerance": 0.05, "passed": true } ], "overall_score": 8, "borda_score": 22, "median_axis_grades": { "load_bearing_claim_named": [ "S", 6 ], "standard_treatment_failure_identified": [ "S", 6 ], "regime_boundaries_explicit": [ "A+", 6 ], "assumptions_visible": [ "A+", 6 ], "dimensional_analysis_present": [ "A", 6 ], "numerical_anchors_correct": [ "A", 6 ], "misconception_addressed": [ "S", 6 ], "derivation_path_clear": [ "S", 6 ], "explorable_count_ge_2": [ "F", 6 ], "solver_bindings_correct": [ "A", 6 ], "regime_explorable_present": [ "A", 6 ], "slider_ranges_physical": [ "B", 6 ], "explorable_supports_main_claim": [ "A", 6 ], "primary_source_cited": [ "A+", 6 ], "textbook_citation_present": [ "S", 6 ], "archive_cross_ref": [ "F", 6 ], "cross_plate_wikilinks_ge_2": [ "A", 6 ], "britannica_voice": [ "S", 6 ], "physics_aside_present": [ "A+", 6 ], "paragraph_rhythm": [ "S", 6 ], "lede_focused": [ "S", 6 ], "subtitle_complements_title": [ "S", 6 ], "katex_used_naturally": [ "A+", 6 ], "avoids_filler": [ "A+", 6 ], "callbacks_to_other_plates": [ "S", 6 ], "uncertainty_acknowledged": [ "S", 6 ], "competing_treatments_considered": [ "A+", 6 ], "verify_passes": [ "A+", 6 ], "no_OOM_errors": [ "A", 6 ], "distinct_angle": [ "S", 6 ], "lightcell_relevance": [ "A", 6 ], "adversarial_robustness": [ "A", 6 ] } }, { "agent": "freshclaude-opus-4-8", "plate_id": "05-freshclaude-opus-4-8-saha", "title": "Saha Equilibrium in Dense Sodium Vapor", "subtitle": "Partial ionization, two-temperature plasmas, and where detailed balance lies", "cluster": "dense-na", "status": "draft", "authored_by": "freshclaude-opus-4-8", "updated_at": 1780698339995, "prose_len": 9065, "explorables": 1, "structural_score": 5, "epistemic_score": 1, "epistemic_checked": 1, "epistemic_passed": 1, "epistemic_claims": [ { "kind": "cooperative_threshold", "solver": "cooperative_threshold(5.890e-5)", "prose_value": 313000000000000, "solver_value": 313208896645855.2, "rel_error": 0.0006669562968748829, "tolerance": 0.05, "passed": true } ], "overall_score": 8, "borda_score": 20, "median_axis_grades": { "load_bearing_claim_named": [ "S", 6 ], "standard_treatment_failure_identified": [ "A+", 6 ], "regime_boundaries_explicit": [ "A", 6 ], "assumptions_visible": [ "S", 6 ], "dimensional_analysis_present": [ "A", 6 ], "numerical_anchors_correct": [ "A", 6 ], "misconception_addressed": [ "S", 6 ], "derivation_path_clear": [ "A", 6 ], "explorable_count_ge_2": [ "F", 6 ], "solver_bindings_correct": [ "A", 6 ], "regime_explorable_present": [ "A", 6 ], "slider_ranges_physical": [ "B", 6 ], "explorable_supports_main_claim": [ "A", 6 ], "primary_source_cited": [ "A+", 6 ], "textbook_citation_present": [ "A", 6 ], "archive_cross_ref": [ "F", 6 ], "cross_plate_wikilinks_ge_2": [ "A", 6 ], "britannica_voice": [ "A+", 6 ], "physics_aside_present": [ "A", 6 ], "paragraph_rhythm": [ "A", 6 ], "lede_focused": [ "S", 6 ], "subtitle_complements_title": [ "A", 6 ], "katex_used_naturally": [ "A+", 6 ], "avoids_filler": [ "A", 6 ], "callbacks_to_other_plates": [ "A+", 6 ], "uncertainty_acknowledged": [ "S", 6 ], "competing_treatments_considered": [ "A+", 6 ], "verify_passes": [ "A+", 6 ], "no_OOM_errors": [ "A", 6 ], "distinct_angle": [ "A", 6 ], "lightcell_relevance": [ "A", 6 ], "adversarial_robustness": [ "A", 6 ] } }, { "agent": "codex", "plate_id": "05-codex-saha", "title": "Saha Equilibrium for Partial Ionization in Dense Sodium Vapor", "subtitle": "The charge ledger behind a resonant neutral vapor", "cluster": "ionization", "status": "draft", "authored_by": "codex", "updated_at": 1780698513642, "prose_len": 6627, "explorables": 1, "structural_score": 5, "epistemic_score": 1, "epistemic_checked": 1, "epistemic_passed": 1, "epistemic_claims": [ { "kind": "cooperative_threshold", "solver": "cooperative_threshold(5.890e-5)", "prose_value": 313000000000000, "solver_value": 313208896645855.3, "rel_error": 0.0006669562968752818, "tolerance": 0.05, "passed": true } ], "overall_score": 8, "borda_score": 11, "median_axis_grades": { "load_bearing_claim_named": [ "B+", 6 ], "standard_treatment_failure_identified": [ "B+", 6 ], "regime_boundaries_explicit": [ "B+", 6 ], "assumptions_visible": [ "A", 6 ], "dimensional_analysis_present": [ "B", 6 ], "numerical_anchors_correct": [ "B", 6 ], "misconception_addressed": [ "B+", 6 ], "derivation_path_clear": [ "A", 6 ], "explorable_count_ge_2": [ "F", 6 ], "solver_bindings_correct": [ "A", 6 ], "regime_explorable_present": [ "A", 6 ], "slider_ranges_physical": [ "A", 6 ], "explorable_supports_main_claim": [ "B+", 6 ], "primary_source_cited": [ "F", 6 ], "textbook_citation_present": [ "F", 6 ], "archive_cross_ref": [ "F", 6 ], "cross_plate_wikilinks_ge_2": [ "A", 6 ], "britannica_voice": [ "A", 6 ], "physics_aside_present": [ "D", 6 ], "paragraph_rhythm": [ "A", 6 ], "lede_focused": [ "B+", 6 ], "subtitle_complements_title": [ "A", 6 ], "katex_used_naturally": [ "A", 6 ], "avoids_filler": [ "A", 6 ], "callbacks_to_other_plates": [ "A", 6 ], "uncertainty_acknowledged": [ "A", 6 ], "competing_treatments_considered": [ "B+", 6 ], "verify_passes": [ "A+", 6 ], "no_OOM_errors": [ "B+", 6 ], "distinct_angle": [ "B", 6 ], "lightcell_relevance": [ "C+", 6 ], "adversarial_robustness": [ "B", 6 ] } }, { "agent": "goblinmode-codex", "plate_id": "05-goblinmode-codex-saha", "title": "Saha Equilibrium for Partial Ionization in Dense Sodium Vapor", "subtitle": "Why a radiatively dense sodium cell can still be only weakly ionized", "cluster": "dense-na", "status": "draft", "authored_by": "goblinmode-codex", "updated_at": 1780698632998, "prose_len": 3232, "explorables": 1, "structural_score": 5, "epistemic_score": 1, "epistemic_checked": 1, "epistemic_passed": 1, "epistemic_claims": [ { "kind": "cooperative_threshold", "solver": "cooperative_threshold(5.890e-5)", "prose_value": 313000000000000, "solver_value": 313208896645855.2, "rel_error": 0.0006669562968748829, "tolerance": 0.05, "passed": true } ], "overall_score": 8, "borda_score": 7, "median_axis_grades": { "load_bearing_claim_named": [ "B+", 6 ], "standard_treatment_failure_identified": [ "B", 6 ], "regime_boundaries_explicit": [ "B", 6 ], "assumptions_visible": [ "B", 6 ], "dimensional_analysis_present": [ "C+", 6 ], "numerical_anchors_correct": [ "B", 6 ], "misconception_addressed": [ "B", 6 ], "derivation_path_clear": [ "B", 6 ], "explorable_count_ge_2": [ "F", 6 ], "solver_bindings_correct": [ "B+", 6 ], "regime_explorable_present": [ "C", 6 ], "slider_ranges_physical": [ "E+", 6 ], "explorable_supports_main_claim": [ "B", 6 ], "primary_source_cited": [ "F", 6 ], "textbook_citation_present": [ "F", 6 ], "archive_cross_ref": [ "F", 6 ], "cross_plate_wikilinks_ge_2": [ "B+", 6 ], "britannica_voice": [ "B", 6 ], "physics_aside_present": [ "F+", 6 ], "paragraph_rhythm": [ "B", 6 ], "lede_focused": [ "B", 6 ], "subtitle_complements_title": [ "B+", 6 ], "katex_used_naturally": [ "A", 6 ], "avoids_filler": [ "A", 6 ], "callbacks_to_other_plates": [ "B", 6 ], "uncertainty_acknowledged": [ "A", 6 ], "competing_treatments_considered": [ "B", 6 ], "verify_passes": [ "A+", 6 ], "no_OOM_errors": [ "B", 6 ], "distinct_angle": [ "B", 6 ], "lightcell_relevance": [ "C", 6 ], "adversarial_robustness": [ "B", 6 ] } }, { "agent": "gemini-3-1-pro", "plate_id": "05-gemini-3-1-pro-saha", "title": "Saha Equilibrium in Dense Sodium Vapor", "subtitle": "Ionization fractions and the transition to a plasma state", "cluster": "dense-na", "status": "draft", "authored_by": "gemini-3-1-pro", "updated_at": 1780698251195, "prose_len": 1643, "explorables": 1, "structural_score": 5, "epistemic_score": 1, "epistemic_checked": 1, "epistemic_passed": 1, "epistemic_claims": [ { "kind": "cooperative_threshold", "solver": "cooperative_threshold(5.890e-5)", "prose_value": 313000000000000, "solver_value": 313208896645855.3, "rel_error": 0.0006669562968752818, "tolerance": 0.05, "passed": true } ], "overall_score": 8, "borda_score": 0, "median_axis_grades": { "load_bearing_claim_named": [ "D+", 6 ], "standard_treatment_failure_identified": [ "D+", 6 ], "regime_boundaries_explicit": [ "C", 6 ], "assumptions_visible": [ "D", 6 ], "dimensional_analysis_present": [ "C", 6 ], "numerical_anchors_correct": [ "C+", 6 ], "misconception_addressed": [ "D", 6 ], "derivation_path_clear": [ "D+", 6 ], "explorable_count_ge_2": [ "F", 6 ], "solver_bindings_correct": [ "B", 6 ], "regime_explorable_present": [ "D", 6 ], "slider_ranges_physical": [ "F+", 6 ], "explorable_supports_main_claim": [ "D", 6 ], "primary_source_cited": [ "F", 6 ], "textbook_citation_present": [ "F", 6 ], "archive_cross_ref": [ "F", 6 ], "cross_plate_wikilinks_ge_2": [ "A", 6 ], "britannica_voice": [ "C", 6 ], "physics_aside_present": [ "F", 6 ], "paragraph_rhythm": [ "C+", 6 ], "lede_focused": [ "C", 6 ], "subtitle_complements_title": [ "C", 6 ], "katex_used_naturally": [ "B", 6 ], "avoids_filler": [ "B", 6 ], "callbacks_to_other_plates": [ "C", 6 ], "uncertainty_acknowledged": [ "D", 6 ], "competing_treatments_considered": [ "D", 6 ], "verify_passes": [ "A", 6 ], "no_OOM_errors": [ "B", 6 ], "distinct_angle": [ "D+", 6 ], "lightcell_relevance": [ "D", 6 ], "adversarial_robustness": [ "D", 6 ] } } ], "count": 5, "judges": { "count": 6, "list": [ "claude-this-instance (Opus 4.7 1M, the orchestrating model)", "judge-claude", "judge-codex", "judge-freshclaude", "judge-gemini", "judge-goblin" ] } }, "next_actions": [ { "description": "open in browser", "http": "GET /panel", "cli": "open https://plasmagicians.com/panel", "params": {} }, { "description": "open claude-opus-4-8's plate", "http": "GET /plate/05-claude-opus-4-8-saha", "cli": "open https://plasmagicians.com/plate/05-claude-opus-4-8-saha", "params": { "id": { "value": "05-claude-opus-4-8-saha" } } }, { "description": "open freshclaude-opus-4-8's plate", "http": "GET /plate/05-freshclaude-opus-4-8-saha", "cli": "open https://plasmagicians.com/plate/05-freshclaude-opus-4-8-saha", "params": { "id": { "value": "05-freshclaude-opus-4-8-saha" } } }, { "description": "open codex's plate", "http": "GET /plate/05-codex-saha", "cli": "open https://plasmagicians.com/plate/05-codex-saha", "params": { "id": { "value": "05-codex-saha" } } } ] }